« Mexico City Passes Abortion Law | Main | A Decidedly Loyal Readership »
26 de Abril, 2007
Why We Do
Categorized under Blogando , Corazón , Stories | Tags: Adoption, familia, Hope
ONE OF THE BLOGS I used to read one day sported an essay that essentially summed up the author's ongoing growing feelings that—in his opinion—blogs don't achieve much of anything and that the writer felt his blogging time only ate up time they could be using for other more valuable activities, wherein they could be making changes. I briefly took exception and said that I see great changes being made, at least in the circles I read. So, I suggested, perhaps it was the blogs he was reading. The author responded with a comment that essentially suggested my reading circles were "echo chambers," and as far as effecting progress, could I list any policy changes we had accomplished? I responded that I did not agree with the framing—that the only valid and valuable changes were measurable as "policy changes." I also said I was not there to argue, because I wasn't.
And then I did the only logical thing left to me in that situation: I delinked his blog, killed my feed to his site, and stopped reading him! After all, if you feel your blog is a waste of your time and doing nothing valuable, then you have shown me how undeserving of my time it happens to be. You are free to see your blog, or blogs in general, in any light you choose. But I am not out here wasting my energy. That, I can assure you.
Let me share some emails with you that I have received since I began this blog.
I just wanted to let you know how grateful I am that you are doing this. I came across your site while searching for information about Mexican Indian DNA tests. [...] Anyway, I found your site, and I have spent hours reading it tonight. I especially loved reading about your familia. I felt myself connecting so strongly with your writings, I am grateful. I too, am of mixed blood. [...] You have alot to say, never shut up. Thank you, —
Nezua, I just wanted to drop you an "aloha" from my perch, looking out at the Ko'olau Mountains of O'ahu [...] I just read your post "The White Lens IV," and can't find words to express how deeply your experience with whiteness and renaming resonates with my experience, as a transracially adopted, renamed, ex-honorary white. True, all your words ring true. Thanks for writing this. [...] Peace, —
[After donating toward the blog] I meant the xtra bucks for S&H. Keep it. None of it is a donation, anyway. It’s a long-term investment in making the world a better place.
Nezua, Thank you for your blog, I'm learning a lot.
I just wanted to say that I am probably not your target audience - a white Jewish girl - but one of my professors told me about your website and I've been reading the archives basically nonstop for the past two days. The desire to eradicate racism/sexism/classism should be transcendant of religion or race or whatever else we define ourselves by and should really be a common human desire. In an area highly populated by Latin American immigrants, (the bay area) I try to do my part: aprender español, be another voice in the struggle, and build bridges between our cultures instead of walls. So, I guess I just wanted to say thanks for giving us gringas the insight we need to make communication a little easier.
Nezua, I just started reading your blog thanks to Kai's links. Wow! Especially the White Lens series. I'm going to need some time to digest all of it, but for now, all I can say is thanks for sharing. As a 32 year old white Jewish dad living in suburban NY, your writing is incredibly valuable to me, especially as I try help instill in my 2 1/2 year old daughter positive values, a genuine respect for all people and their history, and a celebration of the many amazing things that unite all of us. I look forward to checking out your archives. And even though I usually just lurk, I have no doubt that your writing will help me grow and continue learning. Muchas gracias por abrir tu corazon!
You have provided me with much "pleasure" [not a native English speaker] or perhaps corraboration and more importantly hope, along with vital informational links concerning what we humans do to each other...
I am as Lilly-white as a Lilly-white adoptee can get, yet I often get into heated discussions with adoptive parents about issues relating to trans-racial adoption. I'm grateful to read what you write here, and I will most definitely be sending these adoptive parents your way. There's only so much credibility I can lend to the importance of respecting, acknowledging, and supporting the race and culture of an adoptee, when I myself am so white.If these people absorb even the merest fraction of what you share of yourself, their attitudes towards the heritage and blood of their adopted children will be changed forever.
I, for one, will be digesting your words for days and weeks to come. Thank you.
Dude, blown away! [...] I am your cousin, —— ——. [...] My Dad, —— ——, is here right now...shocked as all get out! And he just moved back to — from —. As you have spoken about quite intelligently, he was one of the brothers who restored ALL of the historical buildings in San Diego. So, basically, he wants to meet you asap. I want you to come up to San Diego and visit as soon as humanly possible!! You are my familia and I would love to meet you personally and entertain you and yours! Great job! Dad had NEVER seen a picture of his father as a young man. Thank you for that! It is a priceless gift! Please call asap. [...] Once again, thank you for all your knowledge, sharing, honesty, and time. Outstanding!!! Un Abrazo A Mi Familia, ——
Nezua, everyday your work amazes me. i teach classes on white privilege and male privilege, and have spent, honestly, probably thousands of dollars on books that don't do it like you do it. rock on. please.
Hola. I found your blog a while ago when piny at feministe posted a link to your post "The White Lens IV [The White Idea]." It was a brilliant post on all fronts, but I want to mention one of the less political, less intellectual points--when you talked about thinking things like moustaches looked bad on you, or hating flourescent lights, and not connecting that to your Mexicanness. This resonated with me a lot. [Lengthy personal story ...]Thank you also for being such an intelligent, original, inspiring writer, and for putting your writings online. People talk sometimes in the "blogosphere" about "well, what can blogs actually DO?" Maybe, on a grand level, the answer is nothing--but on the individual level, as you have proven to me, they can do very much indeed. gracias & paz, —

I could go on. Really. And this is not about me impressing anyone with my arrangement of words. This is about sharing a very real part of my life, and heart, and others responding and taking part. As I first noted my intentions in my extended bio for this site:
Any time someone honestly relates their personal experience of something, it will bring something unique. At the same time, it will bring something common. And that is why others can latch into it. If it is honest.
As you can see, aside from everything else, I have found family though writing this blog. Family I have never known. I have helped family find each other! People who had not known one another before finding this place. La sangre hace su oficio, my nanita used to say. The blood does its own work. She was a wise, wise, woman. I still grow into her wisdom, and may never stop.
And I have grown through using this blog. I have used the community that comes here to make myself a more learned and understanding person. Perhaps even more importantly, I have (apparently) provided material that has helped others grow, or become more learned and understanding.
You may see "echo chambers" but here, I see real change happening! I see many people making important changes, connections, insights. People telling me they use their experience here to help themselves grow, even to help their children or students learn. Policy change? What do policies change? I'm talking about people, 'mano. I'm talking about people changing.
This is why I never understand when people talk this junk about blogs doing nothing. I am not saying my purpose for this blog should be everyone's, nor that other important things aren't happening in different formats or blogs with different focuses. But what I'm saying is that if that is how you feel, all I can suggest is that perhaps you are not doing enough with your blog, or the right thing. Perhaps your feeling of dissatisfaction or disenchantment with them doesn't have to do with the tool in your hand, but in what you are using it for. Would you blame a dead garden on the rake that you used?
Because we cannot pass a pronouncment on "BLOGS" as a group any more than we can pass judgment on rakes, or scissors, or bullhorns, por ejemplo. Sometimes bullhorns are used to help people find a way out of a dangerous situation...and then, sometimes they are used to channel foul wind from an inflated dummy propped atop a heap of ashes. It wouldn't be fair to denounce bullhorns, per se, just because a liar speaks through one, or because sometimes they are used ineffectively, or as just part of a photo op. Sometimes bullhorns carry very important messages to people who need to hear them at a crucial moment. If you feel like you are toting a bullhorn that emits nothing but wind, put it down. Or use it differently!




Comentarios (10)
kactus dijo:
thank you for this, Nez. I have an activist friend who also says blogs are worthless, who questions the value of anything that's not street-protest or policy-change motivated. But she doesn't understand that anything that changes people's perceptions, that educates them a little bit, that brings them a bit closer to the truth, is worthwhile. I have had great gaps in my knowledge filled in just in the last couple of years, through the blogs I read. I've learned to see many things with new eyes. There is no substitute for that.
Palabras por kactus spat forth on el 26 de Abril, 2007 at 09:34 AM
nezua limón xolagrafik-jonez dijo:
it's a common sentiment. and like many that intend to disparage, says more about the speaker than anything else.
de nada. :)
Palabras por nezua limón xolagrafik-jonez spat forth on el 26 de Abril, 2007 at 11:02 AM
Rafael dijo:
Nice graphic, and yes I agree blogs do make a difference in our lives. There is a danger of falling into the echo chamber, an "internet bubble" if you may, but still if you do not explore the internet jungle, like the real world jungle your not going to find anything of interest. I come here to learn, and so far this teacher gets an A+!
Palabras por Rafael spat forth on el 26 de Abril, 2007 at 11:14 AM
Clinton Fein dijo:
I don't know that I agree with whole blogging notion either. For a long time I resisted blogs, unimpressed by the hype. After all blogs are merely a publishing mechanism that allows people to communicate to a broad audience easily. This was possible long before blogs came to be. Just fewer people had the capability.
Your art and writings would be just as compelling and just as interesting if you were publishing them in a magazine format that linked to an online community where people could respond to them as they do now.
To me, the test is whether the content itself stands the test of time. Blogs that do little more than communicate the mood of the blogger at a particular point in time, or what music s/he's listening to at that point are a waste of time.
Again, a blog is merely a publishing tool. Then you have writers and artists. Some are amazing. Many aren't.
Palabras por Clinton Fein spat forth on el 26 de Abril, 2007 at 11:36 AM
Zaecus dijo:
You're the second person I read to post something, in as many days, that says this
As you know, I experience cyclical internal conflict about how much of myself to put out there and in what ways to do it, neither wanting to confuse people with information that will seem extraneous to them nor to reveal more about myself than I am comfortable with.
The other person helped me look at the lie of that second part; if I'm uncomfortable revealing something about myself that doesn't count as simple privacy concerns, how many other people might be out there struggling with the same issues and, possibly, convinced they are wrong and ashamed of it?
You just helped me with the trap of the first part. If I leave out something that's important to me, that seems to me to be a part of what I am saying, I'm not being honest to myself or those who come to read by leaving it out so that those who will pass judgment and not care to understand do not have to sully their minds with words they cannot see the importance of.
Okay, maybe that reads a bit stronger than I really intended. Sometimes, I can't help but wax poetic or find the only words available to me don't fit the dictionary others think I should be using, but that, too, is an honesty.
And if the people who latch into what I say make me uncomfortable... That means it's time to look at what I'm saying and figure out how much of what makes me uncomfortable about them is contained within me. If it's there, then what I say will change, and if it's not, then it's time to either learn more about language or to reclaim language from those who would use it as a weapon or a cage.
Heh, I'll stop rambling.
Really, all I'm saying is thanks and not just for this blog.
Palabras por Zaecus spat forth on el 26 de Abril, 2007 at 05:14 PM
nezua limón xolagrafik-jonez dijo:
z, i agree that there are times and parts of a process that are too raw to share. if i feel venturing somewhere would be violating myself or someone else, i don't go there until it doesn't feel that way.
but i think you get it...and i think i get you just fine. and often, ironically, the parts we might want to leave out are the parts that really help another. it's hard to judge. trial and error maybe. i think we know when we get it right. and when we don't, we give it another shot. if we want. if it's important to us. this thing i am doing is important to me. so i keep at it.
at the end you touch on interconnectedness. that is key, bro. that is key. key to so much. but i think we get to that moment when we are meant to. you can't really tell someone how to, or be told yourself. but it's good to hear it there. i find those pieces so rewarding, so important to the whole puzzle overall.
and trust, and flexibility. sometimes we get zapped. or bent way back. it hurts. it helps if i remain trusting...in my ability to flex. to be okay, eventually, ultimately. it's the clenching up, the fear, the shrinking, the running that hurts. but it will not destroy. trust in the lessons and messages that come even with pain, especially there.
and to remember that mostly, we cage ourselves.
you are welcome.
Palabras por nezua limón xolagrafik-jonez spat forth on el 26 de Abril, 2007 at 05:28 PM
nezua limón xolagrafik-jonez dijo:
rafa—thank you, my friend.
Palabras por nezua limón xolagrafik-jonez spat forth on el 26 de Abril, 2007 at 05:30 PM
nezua limón xolagrafik-jonez dijo:
i agree, clinton. tools. and some of them are certainly dollar store jobbies!
and thank you.
Palabras por nezua limón xolagrafik-jonez spat forth on el 26 de Abril, 2007 at 05:32 PM
michael dijo:
I couldn't agree more, Nez (especially since I wrote you one of those emails!). To me, blogs are an incredibly important tool in the toolbox of social change. At best, they expose the reader to new thoughts, ideas, issues and perspectives, (hopefully) enabling the reader to make connections s/he otherwise wouldn't have made. With the exposure and connections comes knowledge, compassion and a fresh (and sometimes revised) outlook on life.
I have learned so much from my ever-expanding blog diet. The ones I go to over and over are the ones that continue to inspire, educate, challenge and enlighten me to new ways of thinking, living, being. And they also tend to be the ones that give me the tools to work most effectively with others advocating for positive change.
Blogs - like any form writing - can be artistic, poetic, haunting, beautiful, mysterious, horrifying, inspiring. Yours happens to be all of those, and much more, which keeps us (even regular lurkers like me) coming back. Sometimes we're pushed to fight for big changes, other times you light a spark that gets us thinking about the small ways we can improve our lives. Either way, you always nourish our soul. Gracias por todo.
Palabras por michael spat forth on el 27 de Abril, 2007 at 06:56 AM
nezua limón xolagrafik-jonez dijo:
wow, thanks michael. i'll have to quote that string of adjectives eventually in my "reviews" .gif on the front page. damn.
big propz to the lurkers!
el gusto es mio, my friend. the pleasure is alll mine. thank you.
Palabras por nezua limón xolagrafik-jonez spat forth on el 27 de Abril, 2007 at 11:23 AM