« Univision, Now With Extra Clinton Bias! | Main | My Morality, Your Body, Our Plates. »
29 de Enero, 2008
Bendixen for Obama!
Categorized under Política Estados Unidos | Tags: Change, Clinton, hype, Obama, Sergio Bendixen
I'M BEGINNING TO GET ANNOYED as I keep hearing what a rift exists between Latinos and Blacks, or how Latinos won't vote for blacks. Specifically, that Obama will be hurt by this "fact."
A few weeks ago, Sergio Bendixen, a Clinton pollster and Latino expert, publicly articulated what campaign officials appear to have been whispering for months. In an interview with Ryan Lizza of the New Yorker, Bendixen explained that "the Hispanic voter -- and I want to say this very carefully -- has not shown a lot of willingness or affinity to support black candidates."The spin worked. For the last several weeks, it's been on the airwaves (Tucker Carlson, "Hardball," NPR), generally tossed off as if it were conventional wisdom. And it has shown up in sources as far afield as Agence France-Presse and the London Daily Telegraph, which wrote about a "voting bloc traditionally reluctant to support black candidates."
The spin also helped shape the analysis of the Jan. 19 Nevada caucus, in which Clinton won the support of Latino voters by a margin of better than 2 to 1. Forget the possibility that Nevada's Latino voters may have actually preferred Clinton or, at the very least, had a fondness for her husband; pundits embraced the idea that Latino voters simply didn't like the fact that her opponent was black.
But was Bendixen's blanket statement true? Far from it, and the evidence is overwhelming enough to make you wonder why in the world the Clinton campaign would want to portray Latino voters as too unrelentingly racist to vote for Barack Obama.
I don't appreciate this little seed that Hillary pollster Sergio Bendixen has planted. It is division and the digging deeper of old wounds by those who have no business doing such things. Granted, Bendixen is known for his multilingual polls and extensive understanding of the "Hispanic" population.
The South Florida Sun-Sentinel reported that Bendixen "has earned the undisputed title of being the leading pollster of Hispanics in the country." The Columbia Journalism Review identifies Bendixen as the pioneer of multilingual polling with surveys conducted in as many as 12 different languages.—Meet the President, Bendixen and associates
Hard to argue with that! So maybe we should pay a little attention to what the man says...
Here's Bendixen in April of 2007, talking about the results of polling the youth of California, a place which he states is "long perceived as a bellwether for the rest of the nation, and one of the most diverse states in the nation." The article is titled "What the Youth Know."
California’s young people, as reflected in our poll, are strong believers in the American Dream. Overwhelmingly—across race, ethnicity and gender—they believe strongly in their ability to determine their own futures. Despite obstacles, they expect to create successful lives for themselves and imagine a more inclusive and tolerant society for one another. This collective optimism represents a valuable resource for California, and a mirror of what the United States is becoming as a global society.One thing our conversations with California youth made clear is that this generation embraces, rather than fears, the state’s increasing diversity. When asked what defines their identity, they were as apt to cite fashion and music as they were race or ethnicity. The overwhelming majority of young people cited the state’s diversity as a strength and maintain diversity among their immediate circle of friends. Two-thirds had dated someone of a different race, and nearly 90 percent said they would be open to marrying or entering into a life partnership with someone of a different race.
How do we square this? After all, according to Bendixen, "nearly half [of California's youth] are immigrants or the children of immigrants." And I'm guessing that means a whole lot of them are LATINO.
But maybe Bendixen, Clinton pollster, is not invalidating his own recent opinions with hypocrisy. Maybe there is another way to see this.
Because on one hand Bendixen says that Latinos/Hispanics typically have not shown much "affinity" for voting for blacks. And we can assume that his records show this to be true. However, records are voices from the past. And if we go by this well-respected expert's opinion, the voices of California youth are an indication of the nation's future. These are voices that, as New America Media Executive Director Sandy Close puts it "represent the forefront of the cultural continuum. To gauge their hopes, fears and perspectives about the future is to glimpse who we are becoming as a society.”
So again, we come down to it. The idea that Clinton is the candidate of the establishment, the past, and the tired divisions that lie there, while Obama is the candidate of change, hope, and the future has now been reinforced even by Clinton pollster Sergio Bendixen, "who is recognized as the preeminent expert in Hispanic public opinion research in the United States and Latin America." The unprecedented numbers of young people turning out for Obama must be added to Bendixen's findings. Doing so leaves us with little room to argue with the expert. Qué no, Sergio?




Comentarios (16)
atlasien dijo:
According to some of this silly coverage one would think Latinos and black people are like oil and water or lions and polar bears.
Obviously there are problems across all groups with racism and stereotyping but it's nowhere near as monolithic as Bendixen wants to make it.
I'll predict there will be growing Latino support for Obama for the simple reason that he now has momentum behind him.
Palabras por atlasien spat forth on el 29 de Enero, 2008 at 07:19 AM
nezua limón xolagrafik-jonez
dijo:
or for the simple reason that we don't like being told who to hate. or because he is taking certain stances that do appeal to some Latinos. as you say, there is no type that can contain all of us, and we all have our reasons. but i'm guessing that no latino likes being told, and especially by whites, who we are incapable of supporting! as i wrote, its a gross, gross wedge that some are trying to push with all their might.
Palabras por nezua limón xolagrafik-jonez
spat forth on el 29 de Enero, 2008 at 07:28 AM
No One of Consequence dijo:
Even the whiff of a division will be exploited by aristocratic whites. They've been doing it literally for centuries. From there perspective, every difference between two groups of people that does not include themselves is a basis for division. They're so good at fighting the class struggle they've created a meme which forbids you from mentioning the class struggle. This shit here is old hat.
Latinos and blacks voted overwhelmingly against Bush recently, where whites found themselves confused by the "uniter." And blacks and latinos vote overwhelmingly Democratic, traditionally. Sounds like points of common perspective to me. And blacks have voted overwhelmingly against right-wing black candidates in the past. So the only way the division narrative can even make sense -- not prove its point, not support its point, but register as a coherent thought expressed in english -- is if you ignore everything you know about ethnicity and voting patterns in the U.S.
We conclude the assertion is fucking bullshit, Q.E.D.
Palabras por No One of Consequence spat forth on el 29 de Enero, 2008 at 08:33 AM
K.VILLA dijo:
What?! I always thought "the preeminent expert in Hispanic public opinion research in the United States and Latin America" was YOU, Nez! This Bendixon dude is a poseur.
Palabras por K.VILLA spat forth on el 29 de Enero, 2008 at 11:46 AM
Fred dijo:
I found this post on huffingtonpost.com from Earl Ofari Hutchinson
""The 'Nevada Phenomenon' instead is the mix of wariness, fear, indifference and even hostility of the majority of Latino voters toward a black candidate.""
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/earl-ofari-hutchinson/nevada-phenomenon-bigge_b_83553.html
I was shocked that someone could generalize all Latino voters in that way..
Palabras por Fred spat forth on el 29 de Enero, 2008 at 11:51 AM
El Loco dijo:
I don't see it as necessarily incongruous. It is entirely possible that Latino immigrants bring with them the same prejudices they grew up with on their countries of origin. However, the subsequent generations of Latinos born or raised in the U.S. have a completely different experience during their formative years that may make them more likely to look past race and ethnicity.
Palabras por El Loco spat forth on el 29 de Enero, 2008 at 11:57 AM
mimi dijo:
Politics is one ugly game.
Thanks for calling Sergio on his, with good arguments and evidence.
Palabras por mimi spat forth on el 29 de Enero, 2008 at 12:00 PM
MNC dijo:
UM-I've been reading your blog for a while and really enjoy it.
On this whole "latino/black hatefest" thing the MSM loves so much, it's just another tool of the powers that be to keep us all fighting amongst one another as no one of consequence pointed out.
The f---- up s---- is that people who look like "us" (who ever us is and that includes white people who are getting screwed by white privilege and are in denial) throw their own in the trick bag on the regular.
Don't let'em put you in the trick bag-including Sergio who is clearly bought and paid for.
Palabras por MNC spat forth on el 29 de Enero, 2008 at 12:57 PM
Martymar dijo:
Bill has told Hillary she must triangulate to win. She has unfortunately drank the Kool-Aid. The youth have been underestimated, and this may be the undoing of the triangulation theory. Awesome blog.
Palabras por Martymar spat forth on el 29 de Enero, 2008 at 04:47 PM
RC dijo:
Just to say what no one remembered to mention here: in my little town the majority of the population is Latino Negro {Black Latin}. So what does that mean in terms of voting?
And as for Nez's post, the idea is that the US will be a completely different place sociologically in 25 years due to demographics and the attitudes of all younger citizens. I hope they make a better world for themselves than the one they are getting handed now.
Perhaps if Bendixen polled attitudes over the entire voting spectrum in a Latin country {say Puerto Rico} he might very well find serious and blatant racism is alive and well. I would bet on that, I see it everywhere in the society.
So, if Bendixen is used to polling in all of the Americas he has long ago noticed that Black candidates have a very tough time in politics in Latin America.
Puerto Rico has a large Black population yet very few Afroboriquas are governing.
I'm going to stop now, because the place I usually go next is to start quoting the comments I hear every day about race and they are NOT pretty.
I don't find any fault with what Bendixen has to say in terms of reality and how it applies to where I live. In terms of the US, I am not there and don't know what is going on. As to Bendixen and the spin he gives the polls he says he takes, well, that's politics.
Palabras por RC spat forth on el 29 de Enero, 2008 at 05:56 PM
No One of Consequence dijo:
Many latinos in South America are "white" in their countries; latinos cover a lot of ethnicities. Race in the U.S. is more pathetically linked to melanin content than in other countries due to a couple of historical quirks I won't go into. Upshot: latinos discriminating against blacks elsewhere are often "white" where they are and would be shocked to find out they're not white once they get here. The rules of other countries do not apply to the U.S.
Palabras por No One of Consequence spat forth on el 29 de Enero, 2008 at 06:49 PM
atlasien dijo:
Having lived in Miami I'm familiar with some really ugly racial dynamics. Sometimes when I lived there I felt like everyone hated everyone else. African-Americans versus Caribbean Blacks versus Cuban-American Almost-whites versus Mexican-American/Central-American in an uneasy, informal caste system...
But I think there are also limits to how much people can fear or hate each other before they start realizing they actually have a lot of common interests. So I'm only half-cynical.
I don't think racism(s) coming out of Latin America is better or worse than racism coming out of Anglo America. They're different but definitely interrelated.
I met a black Mexican once (from Veracruz). He told me the worst racism he faced was from Mexicans who'd picked up anti-black attitudes from living in California. That to me is really depressing... how the worst parts of racial stereotypes can also get exported from Anglo to Latin America, and then maybe back again. The other side of the coin (flipping from cynical to idealistic) is that as more people cross borders there's a chance to import and export better ways of getting along and respecting each other.
Palabras por atlasien spat forth on el 29 de Enero, 2008 at 06:49 PM
Preston_P dijo:
Nez, thank you for the follow up on this. It really sickens me how white elites are attempting to create a wedge between black and latino voters. That article you linked was a great read and it debunked many of those myths that Clinton surrogates pushed into the media. Some pundits who repeat such nonsense seem to forget that back in October Hillary Clinton was leading in the polls among black voters. It wasn't until Obama's win in Iowa where the polls made a big shift. Back in October was when we heard that other media-created meme thrown around: "is Barack Obama black enough?" Now since it's been proven he can win a huge amount of black votes, the new story is that Latinos won't vote for him because of racism.
I'm not a fan of Obama's platform or policies, but damn, can a brother get a break or what? I'll probably vote for him despite the fact he's too accomdating to corporate interests, but I'm getting tired of the fake controversies that talking heads such as Tucker Carlson, Pat Buchanan, Chris Matthews, etc., continue to create.
Palabras por Preston_P spat forth on el 29 de Enero, 2008 at 09:35 PM
Cihua Mexica dijo:
Right on!
You also may want to check out this article by Gregory Rodriguez at the LA Times "Clinton's Latino spin"
http://www.latimes.com/news/opinion/commentary/la-oe-rodriguez28jan28,0,1688217.column where he makes some very good points and exposes the Sergio Bendixen lie, excuse me 'spin'. (And the difference is?)
"The Clinton campaign's assertion that Latinos historically haven't voted for black candidates is divisive -- and false." January 28, 2008
Palabras por Cihua Mexica spat forth on el 30 de Enero, 2008 at 01:22 AM
Rixen dijo:
I am not Hispanic, but black. My quest today has been to unravel the tension there exists between our two ethnicities. I came across this impressive blog, and I think the healing can begin. Why is anyone still trying to divide us? I had no qualms with Hispanics or Latinos until the past two years. As the Hispanic population in Decatur, AL (hicktown, of all places! why there? I did not even want to live there), I noticed that I was receiving some hostility from 3/4 of the Hispanics I ran across in public. I could not understand it. Just 7 years prior, Magaly had been one of my 3 best friends. Her mother spoke no English, but fed me and showed me she loved me through any language barrier. I could not get past it. I was not brought up to hate anyone. As I try to find out why this sentiment exists, I become more confused. Honestly, I know every man holds his prejudices (be they race-related or not); but this division needs to stop. Seriously. By reading this blog, it seems that we are on our way to eliminating this.
Palabras por Rixen spat forth on el 3 de Junio, 2008 at 05:27 PM
nezua
dijo:
well, you are welcome here, amigo.
i think it can cut both ways. and all over. mexicans catch hell from all other latinos pretty much, there is rivalry all over, and it has been visited upon the Brown™ by years and years of white supremacy and slavery and conquest and imperialism and now so many want to be "white" or want to hate on other members of The Brown™ so they can model the same shapes of conquest and racism and supremacy. we do it within our own minds to our selves and to others who suffer it as well.
what can we do but try to break that behavior in our own lives. all of us, all colors. especially those who benefit most from perpetuating it.
'm sorry you've met hostility. i thank you for writing here honestly from your own life experience.
Palabras por nezua
spat forth on el 3 de Junio, 2008 at 05:40 PM